Skip to content
Join Our Press Club
  • Join Our Press Club
  • logo
  • logo
  • City Hall News
    • City Council Meetings
    • Council Standing Committees
    • Advisory and Sub-Committees
    • Citizen-Majority Boards and Agencies
      • Tribunals
        • Hamilton Committee of Adjustment
      • Hamilton Library Board
      • Police Services Board
  • Planning & Developments
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Press Club
  • Email Edition
  • Join Our Press Club

TPR Hamilton | Hamilton's Civic Affairs News Site - Comprehensive Coverage of Hamilton's Civic Affairs

TPR Hamilton | Hamilton's Civic Affairs News Site (https://thepublicrecord.ca/2022/01/ontario-land-tribunal-approves-mid-rise-building-on-main-west/)

  • City Hall News
    • City Council Meetings
    • Council Standing Committees
    • Advisory and Sub-Committees
    • Citizen-Majority Boards and Agencies
      • Tribunals
        • Hamilton Committee of Adjustment
      • Hamilton Library Board
      • Police Services Board
  • Planning & Developments
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Press Club
  • Email Edition

Ontario Land Tribunal Approves Mid-Rise Building on Main West

Joey Coleman By Joey Coleman, Editor | January 27, 2022

HANDOUT/via Urban Solutions

Rendering of the planned mid-rise Sanders Garden Condos

The Ontario Land Tribunal has declared the Ainslie Wood Westdale Secondary Plan (AWWSP) “dated” ruling that the 2005 plan does not comply with current provincial planning policies and using the plan “would have a detrimental effect on achieving good planning outcomes as envisioned by provincial policy.”

The statement comes in a 32-page decision approving a nine-storey residential midrise at 69 Sanders Boulevard and 1630 Main Street West, approximately 800 metres west of the McMaster University campus, nearly across from the Fortino’s plaza.

The site is along the proposed HSR rapid transit BLAST network with future expansion of the B-Line LRT planned to University Plaza.

When built, the condominium building will contain 160 residential units. There will be 22 townhouses behind the building to create a transition into the surrounding residential neighbourhood.

The City of Hamilton “adamantly opposed” the proposal, telling the Ontario Land Tribunal that the character of the Main Street West in Ainslie Wood is that of a “stable residential neighbourhood.”

The City’s planner argued that the AWWSP should supersede the Urban Hamilton Official Plan, the city-wide planning document that identifies arterial roads as appropriate for intensification.

The City argued three-storey townhouses are the appropriate built form for the site.

The permitted height “would be reduced to 3-storeys or perhaps 4-storeys at the most”, the Tribunal wrote in response to the City’s submission.

The Tribunal accepted and agreed with the opinion of the developer’s planner.

Registered professional planner Matt Johnson, of Urban Solutions, stated the development was appropriate for a major arterial road and that the Main West community is in the process of intensifying to higher-density uses.

Johnson submitted that Main West near the planned Light Rail Transit corridor is an appropriate and proper corridor to intensify due to its proximity to major institutions, commercial and retail centres and higher-order transit.

The City agreed the site has adequate water, sanitary and stormwater infrastructure, and traffic can be accommodated within the existing road network.

In its arguments, the City stated the development does not meet the angular plane and shadow requirements when the urban design guidelines of the Downtown Secondary Plan are applied to this site.

The Tribunal rejected both arguments. The balconies of the neighbouring building are already shadowed by their own building.

“The Tribunal finds that the reference in the AWWSP to absolute limits on heights and densities is an unreasonable and overly rigid policy expectation that, if enforced literally,” writes OLT Member Anthony Prevedel, “would have a detrimental effect on achieving good planning outcomes as envisioned by provincial policy.”

Prevedel declined to issue a holding provision requested by the City, writing “that there is no need to have a Holding Provision, as this would add another layer of bureaucracy to the process.”

The development application will now proceed to the completion of technical studies, reports, drawings, and Site Plan approvals.

Urban Solutions is posting all planning documents on its website here: https://urbansolutions.info/sanders-garden-condo/

Filed Under:
  • Ontario Land Tribunal (formerly known as the Ontario Municipal Board and the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal)
  • Planning and Development
  • 69 Sanders Boulevard and 1630 Main Street West (Hamilton)

2 thoughts on “Ontario Land Tribunal Approves Mid-Rise Building on Main West”

  1. Pingback: Ontario Land Tribunal Approves Intensification on West 5th and Stone Church | The Public Record | Hamilton's Civic Affairs News Site

  2. Pingback: OLT Approves 11-storey building at 325 Highway 8 in Stoney Creek | The Public Record | Hamilton's Civic Affairs News Site

Latest Newsletter Edition

  • The Public Record Email Edition for Wednesday, February 1, 2023

TPR Email Edition in your Inbox

Hamilton's only curated newsletter that gives you the information you need to know about City Hall.

The 155 Podcast

The 155 Podcast

The Public Record's podcast of ideas that matter to Hamiltonians and the health of our democracy.

The Public Record Press Club

The Public Record Press Club

The Public Record is a reader funded local news site that depends on your support to provide journalism for all Hamiltonians.

Become a Press Club member today and help TPR grow local journalism here in Hamilton

About The Public Record

The mission of The Public Record is to provide informed coverage of Hamilton’s civic affairs to enable all residents to fulfill the responsibilities of citizenship.


The Public Record

  • The Public Record
  • Support The Public Record, Become a Member of Our Press Club
  • Our Mission As The Public Record
  • Code of Ethics and Journalistic Practice
  • Corrections and Errors
  • Equipment and Software Used by ThePublicRecord.ca
  • Our Funders. Members of The Press Club
  • Newsletter Edition
  • Our Staff and Contributors
  • Use Our Content: Our Licensing
  • The Public Record’s Privacy Policy

The Public Record is an independent publication led by independent Hamilton journalist Joey Coleman, which is funded solely by reader support.

The Public Record does not accept any payment for stories, does not accept advertising, and does not exchange favourable coverage for access.

Contact the Editor: editor@thepublicrecord.ca

The Public Record is registered as a limited liability corporation with the Province of Ontario (2617942 Ontario Inc.), and our HST number is 77290 4280

Search This Site

Browse Archives

Unless otherwise stated, All Original Content is Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Built with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Institute for Nonprofit News.

Back to top ↑